As Huey Lewis once opined in a catchy mid-80's ditty, "It's hip to be square." I never could have guessed how prescient Mr. Lewis' words would be.
I've given the Baby Boomers a hard time on a number of occasions. But today you Boomers can relax. I'm going to rant briefly about my own generation -- Gen X. There's been a lot written lately about parents of my generation, and I've been fascinated by some of the discussions that have taken place.
It shouldn't surprise anyone that Generation X has approached parenting differently than prior generations. And as more Gen X-ers have become parents, some common behaviors and trends have begun to emerge. Some Gen X parents are setting the trends, and others are oblivious to them. Most of us are somewhere in the middle. Something is going on, but we're not discussing it. We're just going on about our business.
Then suddenly someone gives it a name. No, not a name -- a label. And we all scatter like cockroaches when the lights have been turned on. Someone dared to label it, to define it, to analyze it, to theorize about why and how it became what it is -- and we must now deny that it ever existed. Or that we were ever a party to it. Hipster parents? Oh, no, not us. We're so un-cool. Grup? Who, me? Alternadad? Surely not I. I've always despised labels.
We put it down and suggest that anyone who actually behaves that way is flawed. How lame. Look at those people trying so hard to be cool.
We question the credibility of those who dare to analyze it and theorize about it. What credibility to they have? They don't speak for me.
We don't take the time to consider the strengths and weaknesses of someone's analysis or theory (yes, I see his point here, but I don't quite buy this later part). We don't bother to examine the possibility that hipness and coolness aren't really the defining traits in all of this. Instead, we just reject it in full, saying don't you dare try to label me.
As Gen X-ers (and this is where I part company with my generation), we refuse to allow ourselves to be labeled, defined, categorized. Why? Are we that unable to acknowledge that our behavior isn't entirely unique? Are we that unable to look at ourselves in relation to others?
Maybe our ironic detachment prevents us from embracing any type of label. Maybe we're fighting the battle of who could care less. Or maybe, deep down, we are so obsessed with being hip and cool and indie-alterna-whatever that when the lights come on and the trend is revealed and the labels are applied, we must quickly move on to the next thing to avoid becoming part of the dreaded mainstream.
I hope that's not it.
Because sadly, in running from the hipster parent label, we're running smack into the mainstream -- back into the Boomer parenting model that we were so successfully turning on its ear.
February 13, 2007
Just Don't Call Me "Late For Dinner"
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

7 comments:
Fantastic post. Thank you for that. I think you are totally right. The truth is, we're all silently judging each other and being judged. And I think with everything so public now, people aren't "quiet" with their judgments.
I'm done fighting it, though. Because it's so silly. I mean, does anyone REALLY care how I dress? Or how I dress my child? Or whether or not I like indie rock? I don't see how that's at all relevent to my parenting "style". My personal style, sure. And there is a difference contrary to what the critics are saying.
Again, great post!
I'm truly not being dismissive. There IS thought here. But seriously. When the whole GenX label came out with its slacker contexts, the age group it labeled was too young for me and I definitely didn't fit into the slacker, grunge mold they were portraying. Now we're supposed to be hipster parents and by denying the label, well OF COURSE! we're playing into it even more. Right, if you listen to everyone who says they were never cool there was not a cheerleader or a football captain at any highschool in the US 20 years ago.
What's the purpose of the "hipster parent" label? I'm kinda cynical and I feel like it's a corporate attempt to find a way to put us all in an easy box for marketing purposes. How many of us really have the time to wonder if we're cool or not? This whole argument is such a Western conceit. Yes, we're all the same and we're all different. I'm nice, and thoughful, and sometimes I say the wrong thing in public, and I work hard, and my kids get sick, and wear hand-me-down clothes with whatever the heck they happen to have printed on the front (so far, no che), and sometimes I go out and hear music and night, and sometimes I fall asleep on the couch at 8:30 after reading them a story. I'm almost 39.
It's not "don't you dare", it's truly, genuinely "I don't think you know me that well".
I totally see your point, Mrs. D. But like GGC and Deb, I'm ready to give up on all the labeling. Either way, you can't win. And really, you're right. Who could care less? In fact, at this point, I think I'm almost ready to write a post, "In Defense of Hipster Parenting."
Nah...on second thought, I think I'll just clean the wheels off my Bugaboo, wash my daughter's Sonic Youth t-shirt, and smoke some weed!
(in all seriousness, great post. Enjoyed hearing your perspective on all this.)
I wonder how much press the whole hipster parenting thing would've gotten if Pollack's book had never been released? It seems every article uses AlternaDad as a jumping point. But I do think Deb got it right -- the hipster parenting label is for marketing purposes.
And even though I'm far from hip, they can call me whatever they want as long as the don't label me a Bad Parent.
Chag, a lot of the buzz on this started last spring when the NY Times ran a piece on "grups" -- the urban hipster parents. But the launch of Babble and the release of Alternadad so close together definitely brought a lot more attention to it.
I think marketing definitely has something to do with labels and our resistence to them, but there's also a lot about generational identity in all of this that I find really interesting.
Yes yes yes yes YES! You've so been able to put your finger on exactly what's been bothering me about all this...Something is going on, but we're not discussing it. We're just going on about our business.
We're just listening to the music we've always liked, and putting our kids in what we'd wear. I don't know how much thought or even rebellion is going into it.
I suppose there's more irony and cynicism inherent in our own gen's subculture so perhaps that what makes for good headlines.
First time commenter, but I'm delurking because this is an absolutely fantastic post. Very thought-provoking and nicely articulated. Mrs. D, I would love it if you posted this to Indie Bloggers - if you forgot your password let me know, but I have to make this oh so humble request because this is a truly great post that hasn't been discussed very much. And it's too good not to. -stacy (IB)
Post a Comment